Compare price, profitability, solvency, and SEC-reported financials side by side—before deciding which assumptions deserve a closer look.
FY 2025 · View financials
Decision snapshot: MTB stock price vs MSM: inconclusive Relative valuation is incomplete for this pair. Review the available filing metrics before drawing a conclusion.
Quick read
Each company valued on the other's multiple, then compared with the market price.
Implied fair value · at MSM's multiple
Needs MSM P/E.
Implied fair value · at MTB's multiple
Needs MTB P/E.
Live quote
Price unavailable
Metric by metric
Filter, sort, and scan the equity metrics that matter most for banks: book value, tangible book, returns, and operating efficiency.
Lower is better
Lower is better
Profitability lag
Asset efficiency lag
Lower is better
Statements
Bank-focused income statement and equity metrics aligned to the reporting windows.
SEC periods: MTB FY 2025 (ended Dec 31, 2025) · MSM FY 2025 (ended Aug 30, 2025). Fiscal years are not aligned.
Trendline
Five fiscal years of revenue, earnings, and margins before underwriting a re-rating.
Price framework
Tangible book and profitability anchor a bank, not enterprise value.
Deposits and cash-like balances distort enterprise value for banks, so this section reads equity value, tangible book and profitability instead.
Price / book
Market cap
—
Tangible equity
$20.64B
Price / tangible book
—
Price / book
—
Return on equity
9.8%
Return on assets
1.3%
Efficiency ratio
54.3%
Price / book
Market cap
—
Tangible equity
$579.05M
Price / tangible book
—
Price / book
—
Return on equity
14.4%
Return on assets
8.1%
Efficiency ratio
—
Price framework
Discounted free cash flow, then bridged to a per-share price. Same assumptions applied to both companies.
M&T BANK CORPORATION · implied price per share
Bank model off — standard DCF modelling is disabled for financial institutions.
MSC INDUSTRIAL DIRECT CO., INC. · implied price per share
Bear
$28.08
Base
$33.03
Bull
$37.99
Balance sheet health
Financial health checks to separate durable balance sheets from potential value traps.
Financial strength on a 0–9 scale.
Bankruptcy-risk signal from balance sheet and earnings power.
Not enough data to score either balance sheet.
Debt / equity
Total debt against shareholders' equity
0.45x
0.38x
Net debt / EBITDA
Leverage against operating earnings
0.07x
1.06x
Cash and equivalents
Liquid reserves on the balance sheet
$12.32B
$83.25M
Total debt
Interest-bearing obligations outstanding
$13.06B
$532.98M
Comparable set
Where the pair sits against the wider banking comparable set.
Keep comparing
Open adjacent comparisons from the same industry to pressure-test the read across multiple pairs.
JPMorgan Chase & Co.
MTB vs JPM
Bank of America Corporation
MTB vs BAC
Wells Fargo & Company
MTB vs WFC
Citigroup Inc.
MTB vs C
PNC FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP, INC.
MTB vs PNC
W.W. GRAINGER, INC.
MTB vs GWW
GENUINE PARTS CO
MTB vs GPC
WESCO INTERNATIONAL INC
MTB vs WCC
FASTENAL CO
MTB vs FAST
Live quote
LLM-powered synthesis
An on-demand narrative read of the same deterministic data.
The deterministic comparison remains available. Sign in when you want an on-demand narrative synthesis of the same data.
