Compare price, profitability, solvency, and SEC-reported financials side by side—before deciding which assumptions deserve a closer look.
Decision snapshot: MGEE stock price vs NFG: inconclusive Relative valuation is incomplete for this pair. Review the available filing metrics before drawing a conclusion.
Quick read
Each company valued on the other's multiple, then compared with the market price.
Implied fair value · at NFG's multiple
Needs NFG P/E.
Implied fair value · at MGEE's multiple
Needs MGEE P/E.
Price unavailable
Metric by metric
Where each company leads, and how wide the gap is.
Higher is better
Reported gross margin
Operating income + D&A
Lower is better
Not comparable
Lower leverage
Statements
Annual statements in reported currencies, with calculations and source evidence.
Values retain reported currencies and share bases. Select a figure to inspect its period, calculation and filing inputs. Differences require compatible units and periods.
Explore enterprise value and market valuation multiples in the valuation sections.
Trendline
Eight period-end years of reported revenue, earnings, and margins. Periods and currencies are shown with the data.
Price framework
USD market cap plus reported borrowing debt, less cash and equivalents. This EV proxy excludes investments, preferred stock and noncontrolling-interest adjustments.
Complete market value, debt and cash evidence is required for enterprise value.
Complete market value, debt and cash evidence is required for enterprise value.
Price framework
The same filing-backed model used on each company's valuation page, with company-specific inputs and calculated scenarios.
MGE Energy, Inc. · implied price per share
Latest annual free cash flow must be positive to qualify the filing-backed baseline.
NATIONAL FUEL GAS COMPANY · implied price per share
Bear
-$9.77
Base
-$6.10
Bull
-$1.32
Balance sheet health
Inspect reported liquidity and leverage alongside historical financial-health checks.
Financial strength on a 0–9 scale.
Bankruptcy-risk signal from balance sheet and earnings power.
Not enough data to score either balance sheet.
Cash excludes investments. EBITDA is an operating-income-plus-D&A proxy. Missing borrowing categories remain unavailable; select a value to inspect its inputs.
Comparable set
Where the pair sits against the wider comparable set.
Keep comparing
Open adjacent comparisons from the same industry to pressure-test the read across multiple pairs.
ALLIANT ENERGY CORP
MGEE vs LNT
WEC ENERGY GROUP, INC.
MGEE vs WEC
OGE ENERGY CORP.
MGEE vs OGE
Tesla, Inc.
MGEE vs TSLA
DTE ENERGY CO
MGEE vs DTE
PUBLIC SERVICE ENTERPRISE GROUP INC
MGEE vs PEG
NRG ENERGY, INC.
MGEE vs NRG
SPIRE INC
MGEE vs SR
PG&E Corp
MGEE vs PCG
UGI CORP /PA/
MGEE vs UGI
LLM-powered synthesis
An explanation of the financial evidence. Check its snapshot date against the figures above.
This explanation uses an earlier data snapshot or evidence version. Review its generation date and the current figures, or refresh after signing in.
If you believe MGEE can sustain its current multiple despite weaker ROIC and incomplete operating disclosure, then hold or accumulate selectively; otherwise, trim exposure because the P/E and EV/EBITDA comparison versus NFG points to downside and the data do not show a clear fundamental premium.
On the provided P/E-based valuation, MGEE’s implied price of $54.20 sits 32.2% below the current price of $80.00, indicating meaningful downside under this framework. However, MGEE is not clearly expensive versus NFG on operating multiples, and its current price also sits inside its historical band of $72.00 to $88.00, which tempers the bearish signal.
Supporting Metrics
