Compare price, profitability, solvency, and SEC-reported financials side by side—before deciding which assumptions deserve a closer look.
FY 2025 · View financials
Decision snapshot: CINF stock price vs KAR: inconclusive Relative valuation is incomplete for this pair. Review the available filing metrics before drawing a conclusion.
Quick read
Each company valued on the other's multiple, then compared with the market price.
Implied fair value · at KAR's multiple
Needs KAR P/E.
Implied fair value · at CINF's multiple
Needs EPS (TTM) is negative, CINF P/E.
Live quote
Price unavailable
Metric by metric
Where each company leads, and how wide the gap is.
Growth edge
Pricing power
Operating leverage
Lower is better
Not comparable
Lower leverage
Statements
Core statements aligned to each company's latest fiscal year.
SEC periods: CINF FY 2025 (ended Dec 31, 2025) · KAR FY 2025 (ended Dec 31, 2025).
Trendline
Five fiscal years of revenue, earnings, and margins before underwriting a re-rating.
Price framework
Market cap plus debt, less cash.
Price framework
Discounted free cash flow, then bridged to a per-share price. Same assumptions applied to both companies.
CINCINNATI FINANCIAL CORPORATION · implied price per share
Bear
$206.30
Base
$242.70
Bull
$279.11
OPENLANE, Inc. · implied price per share
Bear
$19.27
Base
$22.67
Bull
$26.07
Balance sheet health
Financial health checks to separate durable balance sheets from potential value traps.
Financial strength on a 0–9 scale.
Bankruptcy-risk signal from balance sheet and earnings power.
Not enough data to score either balance sheet.
Debt / equity
Total debt against shareholders' equity
0.05x
0.45x
Net debt / EBITDA
Leverage against operating earnings
-4.18x
0.97x
Cash and equivalents
Liquid reserves on the balance sheet
$13.83B
$141.50M
Total debt
Interest-bearing obligations outstanding
$790.00M
$555.50M
Comparable set
Where the pair sits against the wider comparable set.
Keep comparing
Open adjacent comparisons from the same industry to pressure-test the read across multiple pairs.
ALLSTATE CORP
CINF vs ALL
TRAVELERS COMPANIES, INC.
CINF vs TRV
HARTFORD FINANCIAL SERVICES GROUP, INC.
CINF vs HIG
BERKLEY W R CORP
CINF vs WRB
Chubb Ltd
CINF vs CB
COPART INC
CINF vs CPRT
CARMAX INC
CINF vs KMX
LITHIA MOTORS INC
CINF vs LAD
PENSKE AUTOMOTIVE GROUP, INC.
CINF vs PAG
ASBURY AUTOMOTIVE GROUP INC
CINF vs ABG
GROUP 1 AUTOMOTIVE INC
CINF vs GPI
LLM-powered synthesis
An on-demand narrative read of the same deterministic data.
The deterministic comparison remains available. Sign in when you want an on-demand narrative synthesis of the same data.
Price unavailable
